Ethical, Legal, Regulatory, and Policy Issues Concerning Embryoids: a Systematic Review of the Literature

Overview

Journal Stem Cell Res Ther

Publisher Biomed Central

Date 2023 Aug 22

PMID 37605210

Authors

Ana S Iltis

Grace Koster

Emily Reeves

Kirstin R W Matthews

Affiliations

Soon will be listed here.

Abstract

Recent advances in methods to culture pluripotent stem cells to model human development have resulted in entities that increasingly have recapitulated advanced stages of early embryo development. These entities, referred to by numerous terms such as embryoids, are becoming more sophisticated and could resemble human embryos ever more closely as research progresses. This paper reports a systematic review of the ethical, legal, regulatory, and policy questions and concerns found in the literature concerning human embryoid research published from 2016 to 2022. We identified 56 papers that use 53 distinct names or terms to refer to embryoids and four broad categories of ethical, legal, regulatory, or policy considerations in the literature: research justifications/benefits, ethical significance or moral status, permissible use, and regulatory and oversight challenges. Analyzing the full range of issues is a critical step toward fostering more robust ethical, legal, and social implications research in this emerging area and toward developing appropriate oversight.

Citing Articles

Stem cell-based embryo models: a tool to study early human development.

Wu B, Neupane J, Zhou Y, Zhang J, Chen Y, Surani M Sci China Life Sci. 2025; .

PMID: 39969747 DOI: 10.1007/s11427-024-2741-1.

Advancing the Battle against Cystic Fibrosis: Stem Cell and Gene Therapy Insights.

Shah D, Chorawala M, Pandya A, Kothari N, Prajapati B, Parekh P Curr Med Sci. 2024; 44(6):1155-1174.

PMID: 39676146 DOI: 10.1007/s11596-024-2936-5.

Attitudes of patients with IVF/ICSI toward human embryo in vitro culture beyond 14 days.

Kiya Y, Watanabe S, Harada K, Yui H, Yashiro Y, Muto K Regen Ther. 2024; 26:831-836.

PMID: 39345906 PMC: 11439407. DOI: 10.1016/j.reth.2024.09.005.

Multi-cellular engineered living systems to assess reproductive toxicology.

Lopez I, Truskey G Reprod Toxicol. 2024; 127:108609.

PMID: 38759876 PMC: 11179964. DOI: 10.1016/j.reprotox.2024.108609.

References

Nicolas P, Etoc F, Brivanlou A . The ethics of human-embryoids model: a call for consistency. J Mol Med (Berl). 2021; 99(4):569-579. PMC: 8026457. DOI: 10.1007/s00109-021-02053-7. View

Kagawa H, Javali A, Khoei H, Sommer T, Sestini G, Novatchkova M . Human blastoids model blastocyst development and implantation. Nature. 2021; 601(7894):600-605. PMC: 8791832. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-021-04267-8. View

Clark A, Brivanlou A, Fu J, Kato K, Mathews D, Niakan K . Human embryo research, stem cell-derived embryo models and in vitro gametogenesis: Considerations leading to the revised ISSCR guidelines. Stem Cell Reports. 2021; 16(6):1416-1424. PMC: 8190666. DOI: 10.1016/j.stemcr.2021.05.008. View

Shen H . The labs growing human embryos for longer than ever before. Nature. 2018; 559(7712):19-22. DOI: 10.1038/d41586-018-05586-z. View

Scherer R, Saldanha I . How should systematic reviewers handle conference abstracts? A view from the trenches. Syst Rev. 2019; 8(1):264. PMC: 6836535. DOI: 10.1186/s13643-019-1188-0. View

Sugarman J, Clark A, Fishkin J, Kato K, McCormack K, Munsie M . Critical considerations for public engagement in stem cell-related research. Stem Cell Reports. 2023; 18(2):420-426. PMC: 10242349. DOI: 10.1016/j.stemcr.2023.01.002. View

Mummery C, Anthony E . New guidelines for embryo and stem cell research. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2021; 22(12):773-774. DOI: 10.1038/s41580-021-00429-8. View

Kaebnick G . Toward Public Bioethics?. Hastings Cent Rep. 2017; 47(3):2. DOI: 10.1002/hast.696. View

Pigliucci M . Species as family resemblance concepts: the (dis-)solution of the species problem?. Bioessays. 2003; 25(6):596-602. DOI: 10.1002/bies.10284. View

10.

Matthews K, Iltis A, Marquez N, Wagner D, Robert J, de Melo-Martin I . Rethinking Human Embryo Research Policies. Hastings Cent Rep. 2021; 51(1):47-51. PMC: 7986614. DOI: 10.1002/hast.1215. View

11.

Matthews K, Wagner D, Warmflash A . Stem cell-based models of embryos: The need for improved naming conventions. Stem Cell Reports. 2021; 16(5):1014-1020. PMC: 8185370. DOI: 10.1016/j.stemcr.2021.02.018. View

12.

Boers S, van Delden J, Bredenoord A . Organoids as hybrids: ethical implications for the exchange of human tissues. J Med Ethics. 2018; 45(2):131-139. DOI: 10.1136/medethics-2018-104846. View

13.

Williams K, Johnson M . Adapting the 14-day rule for embryo research to encompass evolving technologies. Reprod Biomed Soc Online. 2020; 10:1-9. PMC: 7052500. DOI: 10.1016/j.rbms.2019.12.002. View

14.

Amadei G, Handford C, Qiu C, De Jonghe J, Greenfeld H, Tran M . Embryo model completes gastrulation to neurulation and organogenesis. Nature. 2022; 610(7930):143-153. PMC: 9534772. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05246-3. View

15.

Warmflash A, Sorre B, Etoc F, Siggia E, Brivanlou A . A method to recapitulate early embryonic spatial patterning in human embryonic stem cells. Nat Methods. 2014; 11(8):847-54. PMC: 4341966. DOI: 10.1038/nmeth.3016. View

16.

Paez A . Gray literature: An important resource in systematic reviews. J Evid Based Med. 2017; 10(3):233-240. DOI: 10.1111/jebm.12266. View

17.

van den Brink S, Baillie-Johnson P, Balayo T, Hadjantonakis A, Nowotschin S, Turner D . Symmetry breaking, germ layer specification and axial organisation in aggregates of mouse embryonic stem cells. Development. 2014; 141(22):4231-42. PMC: 4302915. DOI: 10.1242/dev.113001. View

18.

Lysaght T . Anticipatory Governance and Foresight in Regulating for Uncertainty. Am J Bioeth. 2021; 22(1):51-53. DOI: 10.1080/15265161.2021.2001111. View

19.

Ankeny R, Munsie M, Leach J . Developing a Reflexive, Anticipatory, and Deliberative Approach to Unanticipated Discoveries: Ethical Lessons from iBlastoids. Am J Bioeth. 2021; 22(1):36-45. DOI: 10.1080/15265161.2021.1974976. View

20.

Hsieh H, Shannon S . Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res. 2005; 15(9):1277-88. DOI: 10.1177/1049732305276687. View