Relationship Between Tuberculin Hypersensitivity and Cellular Immunity to Infection in Mice Vaccinated with Viable Attenuated Mycobacterial Cells or with Mycobacterial Ribonucleic Acid Preparations

The migration inhibition technique has been used to study delayed hypersensitivity in vitro by using peritoneal exudate cells and splenic lymphocytes from mice vaccinated with viable cells of the attenuated H37Ra strain of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and from mice vaccinated with ribonucleic acid (myc RNA) preparations obtained from viable mycobacterial cells of the same strain. Inhibition of macrophage migration was noted when purified protein derivative (PPD) or viable H37Ra cells were added to peritoneal exudate cells obtained from mice immunized with viable H37Ra cells and not from mice immunized with myc RNA. Splenic lymphocyte cultures were exposed to the same antigens in vitro. Filtered supernatant fluids from these lymphocyte cultures, when added to peritoneal exudate cells obtained from nonimmunized mice, inhibited migration only when they were obtained from lymphocytes which came from mice immunized with viable H37Ra cells. Injection of PPD intravenously into vaccinated mice resulted in inhibitory supernatant fluids from splenic lymphocyte cultures only when the lymphocytes came from mice immunized with viable H37Ra cells. However, intravenous injection of either viable H37Ra cells or of myc RNA preparations into mice vaccinated with myc RNA occasionally produced inhibitory supernatant fluids when lymphocytes were obtained from these mice. On the other hand, mice vaccinated with myc RNA or viable H37Ra cell preparations were consistently and equally protected against intravenous challenge with the virulent H37Rv strain. Thus, although some evidence was obtained for a delayed type hypersensitivity in mice vaccinated with H37Ra cells or with myc RNA to ribosomal proteins or other proteins associated with the RNA preparation, no evidence of tuberculin hypersensitivity could be detected in any mice vaccinated with the myc RNA. These results argue against a role for tuberculin hypersensitivity in immunity to tuberculous infection.