Distinct Impacts of Aging on the Immune Responses to Extracellular Matrix-based Versus Synthetic Biomaterials

All implanted materials inevitably trigger an acute inflammatory response. The long-term outcome, however, is dependent on the trajectory of this response. This study investigates the effects of aging on the immune response to two commercially available biomaterials. Extracellular matrix-based urinary bladder matrix (UBM) and synthetic polypropylene mesh (PPM) were implanted in young (4 months) and aged (18 months) C57BL/6J mice. Overall, PPM led to a sustained inflammatory response regardless of the age of the mice. In contrast, UBM induced an initial inflammatory response that matured into a pro-regenerative/remodeling response with time, though aged mice exhibited a delayed resolution of inflammation. The PPM-induced response was predominantly pro-inflammatory with consistently higher M1-like macrophage phenotype, whereas the response to UBM was characterized by an anti-inflammatory M2-like phenotype, especially in young mice. RNA sequencing revealed marked age-related differences in gene transcription. At day 7 post-implantation, the young mice with UBM showed a robust upregulation of both pro- and anti-inflammatory pathways as compared to young mice implanted with PPM, however, by day 14, the gene expression profile transitioned into an anti-inflammatory profile. Intriguingly, in aged mice, the response to UBM was distinct with consistent downregulation of inflammatory genes compared to PPM, while the response to PPM in both young and aged animals was largely consistent. Upstream analysis identified cytokines as key drivers of the host response, with IL-4 and IL-13 in young mice, and TNF-α and IL-1β driving chronic inflammation in aged mice. These findings highlight the importance of host age in biomaterial outcome, and the potential of ECM-based materials to mount a favorable response even in the presence of age-related immune dysregulation.