Comparison of Clinical Results Using Hamstring Versus Quadriceps Tendon Graft Versus Bone Patella Tendon in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Surgery: A Randomized Clinical Trial

Overview

Journal Med J Islam Repub Iran

Specialty General Medicine

Date 2024 Dec 16

PMID 39678774

Authors

Ehsan Fallah

Mobin Naghshbandi

Roya Ghafoury

Nima Hosseini Zare

Affiliations

Soon will be listed here.

Abstract

Background: Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is pivotal for restoring knee stability and function in individuals with ACL injuries. While bone-patellar tendon-bone (PT), hamstring tendon (HT), and quadriceps tendon (QT) autografts are commonly employed, their comparative effectiveness remains a subject of ongoing research. This study aims to comprehensively compare the functional outcomes, knee stability, revision rates, and incidence of anterior knee pain associated with these autografts.

Methods: In this randomized clinical trial, adult male participants undergoing primary single-bundle ACL reconstruction were randomized into three groups (PT, HT, QT) using a computer-generated sequence with allocation concealment. Blinded assessments were conducted at 2-, 6-, and 12-months post-surgery to evaluate knee function, stability, and patient satisfaction. The rehabilitation protocol was standardized across groups, including specific exercises and cryotherapy, to minimize postoperative swelling and pain.

Results: A total of 75 participants were followed for 12 months post-surgery. While significant improvements in knee function and stability were observed across all groups, there were no statistically significant differences between the autograft types in terms of revision rates or the incidence of anterior knee pain. Detailed statistical analysis revealed effect sizes and confidence intervals, substantiating the clinical relevance of the findings.

Conclusion: PT, HT, and QT autografts each provide favorable outcomes for ACL reconstruction without significant differences in efficacy up to one year postoperatively.Level of Evidence: Level 2 (Randomized Clinical Trial).

References

Offerhaus C, Albers M, Nagai K, Arner J, Hoher J, Musahl V . Individualized Anterior Cruciate Ligament Graft Matching: In Vivo Comparison of Cross-sectional Areas of Hamstring, Patellar, and Quadriceps Tendon Grafts and ACL Insertion Area. Am J Sports Med. 2018; 46(11):2646-2652. DOI: 10.1177/0363546518786032. View

Adhitya I, Kurniawati I, Sawa R, Wijaya T, Dewi N . The Risk Factors and Preventive Strategies of Poor Knee Functions and Osteoarthritis after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Narrative Review. Phys Ther Res. 2023; 26(3):78-88. PMC: 10730125. DOI: 10.1298/ptr.R0028. View

Pinczewski L, Thuresson P, Otto D, Nyquist F . Arthroscopic posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using four-strand hamstring tendon graft and interference screws. Arthroscopy. 1997; 13(5):661-5. DOI: 10.1016/s0749-8063(97)90199-7. View

Vilchez-Cavazos F, Davila-Martinez A, de la Garza-Castro S, Simental-Mendia M, Garay-Mendoza D, Tamez-Mata Y . Anterior cruciate ligament injuries treated with quadriceps tendon autograft versus hamstring autograft: A randomized controlled trial. Cir Cir. 2020; 88(1):76-81. DOI: 10.24875/CIRU.19001001. View

Landes S, Nyland J, Elmlinger B, Tillett E, Caborn D . Knee flexor strength after ACL reconstruction: comparison between hamstring autograft, tibialis anterior allograft, and non-injured controls. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2009; 18(3):317-24. DOI: 10.1007/s00167-009-0931-9. View

Martin-Alguacil J, Arroyo-Morales M, Martin-Gomez J, Monje-Cabrera I, Abellan-Guillen J, Esparza-Ros F . Strength recovery after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with quadriceps tendon versus hamstring tendon autografts in soccer players: A randomized controlled trial. Knee. 2018; 25(4):704-714. DOI: 10.1016/j.knee.2018.03.011. View

Runer A, Klotz S, Schneider F, Egelseer T, Csapo R, Hoser C . Medial Patellofemoral Ligament Reconstruction Using Pedicled Quadriceps Tendon Autograft Yields Similar Clinical and Patient-Reported Outcomes but Less Donor-Site Morbidity Compared With Gracilis Tendon Autograft. Arthroscopy. 2023; 40(2):438-445. DOI: 10.1016/j.arthro.2023.07.006. View

Wipfler B, Donner S, Zechmann C, Springer J, Siebold R, Paessler H . Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using patellar tendon versus hamstring tendon: a prospective comparative study with 9-year follow-up. Arthroscopy. 2011; 27(5):653-65. DOI: 10.1016/j.arthro.2011.01.015. View

Goldblatt J, Fitzsimmons S, Balk E, Richmond J . Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament: meta-analysis of patellar tendon versus hamstring tendon autograft. Arthroscopy. 2005; 21(7):791-803. DOI: 10.1016/j.arthro.2005.04.107. View

10.

Rotterud J, Sivertsen E, Forssblad M, Engebretsen L, Aroen A . Effect of meniscal and focal cartilage lesions on patient-reported outcome after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a nationwide cohort study from Norway and Sweden of 8476 patients with 2-year follow-up. Am J Sports Med. 2013; 41(3):535-43. DOI: 10.1177/0363546512473571. View

11.

Baker H, Bhattacharjee S, Poff C, Bartolotta C, Athiviraham A . Postoperative Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Quadricep and Patella Tendon Rupture, Infection, and Lysis of Adhesions Decreased Despite Changing Graft Trends Over the Past Decade. Arthrosc Sports Med Rehabil. 2022; 4(4):e1437-e1443. PMC: 9402459. DOI: 10.1016/j.asmr.2022.04.033. View

12.

Suri M, Verma A, Khalid M, Nammour M, Godshaw B . Functional Anterior Knee Pain and Return to Sport Following Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. Ochsner J. 2023; 23(1):27-33. PMC: 10016218. DOI: 10.31486/toj.22.0085. View

13.

Kim S, Kumar P, Oh K . Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: autogenous quadriceps tendon-bone compared with bone-patellar tendon-bone grafts at 2-year follow-up. Arthroscopy. 2009; 25(2):137-44. DOI: 10.1016/j.arthro.2008.09.014. View

14.

Ajrawat P, Dwyer T, Whelan D, Theodoropoulos J, Murnaghan L, Bhargava M . A Comparison of Quadriceps Tendon Autograft With Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone Autograft and Hamstring Tendon Autograft for Primary Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Quantitative Synthesis. Clin J Sport Med. 2019; 31(4):392-399. DOI: 10.1097/JSM.0000000000000765. View

15.

Biau D, Tournoux C, Katsahian S, Schranz P, Nizard R . Bone-patellar tendon-bone autografts versus hamstring autografts for reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligament: meta-analysis. BMJ. 2006; 332(7548):995-1001. PMC: 1450040. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.38784.384109.2F. View

16.

Buescu C, Onutu A, Lucaciu D, Todor A . Pain level after ACL reconstruction: A comparative study between free quadriceps tendon and hamstring tendons autografts. Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc. 2017; 51(2):100-103. PMC: 6197319. DOI: 10.1016/j.aott.2017.02.011. View

17.

Lee J, Lee S, Lee M . Outcomes of Anatomic Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Bone-Quadriceps Tendon Graft Versus Double-Bundle Hamstring Tendon Graft. Am J Sports Med. 2016; 44(9):2323-9. DOI: 10.1177/0363546516650666. View

18.

Anderson J, Lamb S, Barker K, Davies S, Dodd C, Beard D . Changes in muscle torque following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a comparison between hamstrings and patella tendon graft procedures on 45 patients. Acta Orthop Scand. 2002; 73(5):546-52. DOI: 10.1080/000164702321022820 . View

19.

Tigerstrand Grevnerts H, Sonesson S, Gauffin H, Ardern C, Stalman A, Kvist J . Decision Making for Treatment After ACL Injury From an Orthopaedic Surgeon and Patient Perspective: Results From the NACOX Study. Orthop J Sports Med. 2021; 9(4):23259671211005090. PMC: 8053763. DOI: 10.1177/23259671211005090. View

20.

Baawa-Ameyaw J, Plastow R, Begum F, Kayani B, Jeddy H, Haddad F . Current concepts in graft selection for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. EFORT Open Rev. 2021; 6(9):808-815. PMC: 8489469. DOI: 10.1302/2058-5241.6.210023. View