The Secondary Structure of Bacteriorhodopsin Determined by Raman and Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy

The secondary structure of bacterio-opsin (BO), the retinal free protein-component of bacteriorhodopsin (BR), has been determined by Raman spectroscopy. Additional circular dichroism (CD) measurements have revealed only negligible conformational differences between BO in apomembranes and BR in purple membranes. Therefore, the secondary structure of BR was derived from the Raman data of BO. The protein conformation was determined to consist of 72-82% helices, 2-11% beta-strands, and 11-17% beta-turns. Only about half of the helical structures correspond to alpha 1-helices, the other half possess non-alpha 1-helical structures. According to the analysis of the Raman data, the derived secondary structure of BR was obtained with high reliability for all structure classes which can be distinguished by this method within the given uncertainty range. This is a remarkable difference from recently published secondary structural data derived from CD measurements where the helix content was reported to be between 50 and 80%. The inherent experimental and methodological uncertainties of the CD-technique leading to such a range of variation are critically discussed in comparison to the method of Raman spectroscopy. The combined application of Raman and CD spectroscopy, as performed here, is demonstrated to be a substantial improvement in the secondary structure determination of retinal-containing membrane proteins. On the basis of our results, some of the recently proposed structural models of BR with a beta-strand content of more than 11% can be ruled out.