Pathogenic BRCA1 Mutations May Be Necessary but Not Sufficient for Tissue Genomic Heterogeneity: Deep Sequencing Data from Ovarian Cancer Patients

Background: Tissue genomic heterogeneity (t-HET) in patients with epithelial ovarian cancer (OVCA) is related to tissue plasticity, i.e., flexibility to adapt to adverse molecular environments. Here, we interrogated the presence and clinical relevance of OVCA t-HET.

Methods: We applied high-depth (>2000×) sequencing on 297 paraffin tissue samples (fallopian tubes, ovaries, intra-abdominal metastases) from 71 treatment-naïve patients who subsequently received first-line platinum-based chemotherapy. Based on tissue mutation patterns, we distinguished tissue genotypes into: no mutation (33/297 samples; 11.1%), stable (173; 58.2%) and unstable (91; 30.7%). We profiled genotypes per patient and assessed t-HET in 69 patients. Predicted pathogenic mutations refer to germline and/or tissues.

Results: Among all 71 patients, 46 (64.8%) had pathogenic BRCA1 mutations and 15 (21.7%) had BRCA1/2 disruption (i.e., pathogenic mutations with position-LOH). We classified 29 patients with t-HET (42%), all with pathogenic BRCA1; t-HET was observed in 64% with such mutations (p < 0.001). As opposed to non-t-HET, matched tissues in t-HET shared pathogenic BRCA1 (p < 0.001) but not BRCA2 and TP53. Germline BRCA1 mutations in tissues exhibited position-LOH; heterozygous status; or, partial loss of the inherited allele accompanied by additional clonal mutations. Patients with t-HET had worse outcome (log-rank p = 0.048 [progression-free]; p = 0.037 [overall survival]), including 12/15 patients with disrupted BRCA1/2 and 3 BRCA1 carriers with partial germline loss in tissues.

Conclusions: Pathogenic BRCA1 mutations appear necessary but may not be sufficient for the establishment of t-HET. t-HET may be associated with worse outcome, including in patients with disrupted BRCA1/2, which is usually considered as a favourable marker. OVCA t-HET may need to be addressed for treatment decisions.