Are Keratin Proteins a Better Tumor Marker Than Epithelial Membrane Antigen? A Comparative Immunohistochemical Study of Various Paraffin-embedded Neoplasms Using Monoclonal and Polyclonal Antibodies

Epithelial membrane antigen and keratin proteins represent markers of epithelial differentiation that may be detected in routine formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues. Eighty-seven neoplasms, including 48 adenocarcinomas of various types, squamous and transitional cell carcinomas, small-cell anaplastic carcinomas, carcinoid tumors, mesotheliomas, hepatomas, melanomas (metastatic), adrenal cortical carcinomas, germ cell tumors, and extramammary Paget's disease, were assessed to determine the relative effectiveness of these antigens as tumor markers. Immunoperoxidase studies were performed using monoclonal antibodies to epithelial membrane antigen and monoclonal (combined AE1 and AE3) and polyclonal (bovine muzzle keratins) antibodies to keratin proteins. In more than half the cases (50/87%), both markers yielded comparable results. However, in 29 cases (33%), keratin proteins were clearly superior to epithelial membrane antigen as a tumor cell marker. Particular discrepancies were apparent for some gastrointestinal adenocarcinomas, squamous cell carcinomas, hepatomas (hepatocellular type), spindle cell components of mesotheliomas, and carcinoid tumors. Epithelial membrane antigen represented a better marker in eight cases (9%), mainly for small-cell anaplastic carcinomas and some renal cell and pulmonary adenocarcinomas. Adrenal cortical carcinomas, melanomas, and seminomas were nonimmunoreactive for both antigens. Epithelial membrane antigen and keratin proteins represent useful complementary markers in diagnostic surgical pathology.