Stretching Semiflexible Polymer Chains: Evidence for the Importance of Excluded Volume Effects from Monte Carlo Simulation

Semiflexible macromolecules in dilute solution under very good solvent conditions are modeled by self-avoiding walks on the simple cubic lattice (d = 3 dimensions) and square lattice (d = 2 dimensions), varying chain stiffness by an energy penalty ε(b) for chain bending. In the absence of excluded volume interactions, the persistence length l(p) of the polymers would then simply be l(p) = l(b)(2d - 2)(-1)q(b) (-1) with q(b) = exp(-ε(b)/k(B)T), the bond length l(b) being the lattice spacing, and k(B)T is the thermal energy. Using Monte Carlo simulations applying the pruned-enriched Rosenbluth method (PERM), both q(b) and the chain length N are varied over a wide range (0.005 ≤ q(b) ≤ 1, N ≤ 50,000), and also a stretching force f is applied to one chain end (fixing the other end at the origin). In the absence of this force, in d = 2 a single crossover from rod-like behavior (for contour lengths less than l(p)) to swollen coils occurs, invalidating the Kratky-Porod model, while in d = 3 a double crossover occurs, from rods to Gaussian coils (as implied by the Kratky-Porod model) and then to coils that are swollen due to the excluded volume interaction. If the stretching force is applied, excluded volume interactions matter for the force versus extension relation irrespective of chain stiffness in d = 2, while theories based on the Kratky-Porod model are found to work in d = 3 for stiff chains in an intermediate regime of chain extensions. While for q(b) ≪ 1 in this model a persistence length can be estimated from the initial decay of bond-orientational correlations, it is argued that this is not possible for more complex wormlike chains (e.g., bottle-brush polymers). Consequences for the proper interpretation of experiments are briefly discussed.