Evidence for Evolutionary Convergence at MHC in Two Broadly Distributed Mesocarnivores

Variation within major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes is important in recognizing pathogens and initiating an immune response. These genes are relevant in enhancing our understanding of how species cope with rapid environmental changes and concomitant fluctuations in selective pressures such as invasive, infectious diseases. Disease-based models suggest that diversity at MHC is maintained through balancing selection arising from the coevolution of hosts and pathogens. Despite intensive balancing selection, sequence motifs or even identical MHC alleles can be shared across multiple species; three potential mechanisms have been put forth to explain this phenomenon: common ancestry, convergent evolution, and random chance. To understand the processes that maintain MHC similarity across divergent species, we examined the variation at two orthologous MHC-DRB genes in widespread North American Musteloid species, striped skunks (Mephitis mephitis), and raccoons (Procyon lotor). These species are often sympatric and exposed to a similar suite of diseases (e.g., rabies, canine distemper, and parvovirus). Given their exposure to similar selective pressures from pathogens, we postulated that similar DRB alleles may be present in both species. Our results indicated that similar motifs are present within both species, at functionally relevant polymorphic sites. However, based on phylogenetic analyses that included previously published MHC sequences of several closely related carnivores, the respective MHC-DRB alleles do not appear to have been maintained through common ancestry and unlikely through random chance. Instead, the similarities observed between the two mesocarnivore species may rather be due to evolutionary convergence.