Randomised, Multi-centre Study of the Usefulness of the Heat and Moisture Exchanger (Provox HME®) in Laryngectomised Patients

This study included 60 patients (30 in Nice and 30 in Reims), who were randomised between a control group that used no device of this type and a group equipped with the Provox HME®. After 3 months of using the device, a notable improvement was found which was statistically significant with regard to cough (P = 0.00174) and to bronchorrhoea (P = 0.0031), and very close to achieving significance with regard to breathing effort. An overall improvement in the prosthetic (tracheo-oesophageal) voice was found in the 21 patients using the HME® and a voice prosthesis for all of the parameters studied. The device was used daily by 80% of the patients of whom 42% used it day and night at the end of the 3 months. Seven patients suffered from minor cutaneous intolerance (of whom 6 had received radiation therapy), which did not require the use of the HME® to be abandoned (PC). After 3 months, patients were asked the following questions: "Do you feel any improvement?": 92% of affirmative answers; "Are you breathing better?": 88% of affirmative answers; "Are you speaking more easily?": 81% had experienced speech improvement. The general adaptation to the device was judged to be satisfactory for 95% of the patients after 3 months. The results of this randomised study show an improvement in the pulmonary symptoms and in the prosthetic voice after 3 months of using Provox HME®. This light and easy-to-use device appears to us to afford a significantly improved quality of life for laryngectomees and should be offered systematically during functional rehabilitation of these patients.