Validation of a Standardized Method for Enumerating Circulating Endothelial Cells and Progenitors: Flow Cytometry and Molecular and Ultrastructural Analyses

Purpose: Antigenic overlap among circulating endothelial cells (CEC) and progenitors (CEP), platelets, and other blood cells led to the need to develop a reliable standardized method for CEC and CEP quantification. These cells are emerging as promising preclinical/clinical tools to define optimal biological doses of antiangiogenic therapies and to help stratify patients in clinical trials.

Experimental Design: We report the experimental validation of a novel flow cytometry method that precisely dissects CEC/CEP from platelets and other cell populations and provides information about CEC/CEP viability.

Results: Sorted DNA/Syto16(+)CD45(-)CD31(+)CD146(+) CECs, investigated by electron microscopy, were found to be bona fide endothelial cells by the presence of Weibel-Palade bodies. More than 75% of the circulating mRNAs of the endothelial-specific gene, VE-cadherin, found in the blood were present in the sorted population. CECs were 140 +/- 171/mL in healthy subjects (n = 37) and 951 +/- 1,876/mL in cancer patients (n = 78; P < 0.0001). The fraction of apoptotic/necrotic CECs was 77 +/- 14% in healthy subjects and 43 +/- 23% in cancer patients (P < 0.0001). CEPs were 181 +/- 167/mL in healthy donors and 429 +/- 507/mL in patients (P = 0.00019). Coefficients of variation were 4 +/- 4% (intrareader), 17 +/- 4% (interreader), and 17 +/- 7% (variability over 0-72 h), respectively. Parallel samples were frozen by a standardized protocol. After thawing, coefficients of variation were 12 +/- 8% (intrareader), 16 +/- 10% (interreader), and 26 +/- 16% (variability over 0-14 days of frozen storage), respectively.

Conclusions: This procedure enumerates a truly endothelial cell population with limited intrareader and interreader variability. It appears possible to freeze samples for large-scale CEC enumeration during clinical trials. This approach could be enlarged to investigate other angiogenic cell populations as well.