So Many Options, So Little Time: the Roles of Association and Competition in Underdetermined Responding

Overview

Journal Psychon Bull Rev

Specialty Psychology

Date 2008 Nov 13

PMID 19001571

Citations 22

Authors

Hannah R Snyder

Yuko Munakata

Affiliations

Soon will be listed here.

Abstract

How do we make decisions when faced with multiple options? In the domain of language, some evidence suggests that we exert cognitive control in order to respond in such underdetermined situations when a good option is hard to find but not when we must select among competing options. However, this conclusion, and conclusions about the neural substrates supporting underdetermined responding, are made on the basis of measures that confound retrieval and selection demands. The present study introduces measures based on latent semantic analyses that better capture the underlying theoretical constructs of association strength and competition. These measures revealed independent effects of retrieval and selection demands on reaction times in verb generation and sentence completion tasks. These results challenge existing accounts of underdetermined responding and highlight the need for unconfounded measures of association strength and competition in studies of localization. We propose a new model governed by both absolute and relative activation levels of alternative responses.

Citing Articles

Role of cognitive control in resolving two types of conflict during spoken word production.

Steinberg Lowe M, Buchwald A Lang Cogn Neurosci. 2023; 38(8):1082-1097.

PMID: 37927968 PMC: 10622112. DOI: 10.1080/23273798.2023.2202917.

Verbal intelligence and leisure activities are associated with cognitive performance and resting-state electroencephalogram.

Ferrari-Diaz M, Bravo-Chavez R, Silva-Pereyra J, Fernandez T, Garcia-Pena C, Rodriguez-Camacho M Front Aging Neurosci. 2022; 14:921518.

PMID: 36268192 PMC: 9577299. DOI: 10.3389/fnagi.2022.921518.

Accumulating evidence for myriad alternatives: Modeling the generation of free association.

Fradkin I, Eldar E Psychol Rev. 2022; 130(6):1492-1520.

PMID: 36190752 PMC: 10159868. DOI: 10.1037/rev0000397.

Auditory Verb Generation Performance Patterns Dissociate Variants of Primary Progressive Aphasia.

Lukic S, Licata A, Weis E, Bogley R, Ratnasiri B, Welch A Front Psychol. 2022; 13:887591.

PMID: 35814055 PMC: 9267767. DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.887591.

Language Tasks and the Network Control Role of the Left Inferior Frontal Gyrus.

Medaglia J, Harvey D, Kelkar A, Zimmerman J, Mass J, Bassett D eNeuro. 2021; 8(5).

PMID: 34244340 PMC: 8431826. DOI: 10.1523/ENEURO.0382-20.2021.

References

Thompson-Schill S, Botvinick M . Resolving conflict: a response to Martin and Cheng (2006). Psychon Bull Rev. 2006; 13(3):402-8. DOI: 10.3758/bf03193860. View

Siegler R . Strategy choice procedures and the development of multiplication skill. J Exp Psychol Gen. 1988; 117(3):258-75. DOI: 10.1037//0096-3445.117.3.258. View

Persson J, Sylvester C, Nelson J, Welsh K, Jonides J, Reuter-Lorenz P . Selection requirements during verb generation: differential recruitment in older and younger adults. Neuroimage. 2004; 23(4):1382-90. DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.08.004. View

Gold B, Balota D, Jones S, Powell D, Smith C, Andersen A . Dissociation of automatic and strategic lexical-semantics: functional magnetic resonance imaging evidence for differing roles of multiple frontotemporal regions. J Neurosci. 2006; 26(24):6523-32. PMC: 6674026. DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0808-06.2006. View

Martin R, Cheng Y . Selection demands versus association strength in the verb generation task. Psychon Bull Rev. 2006; 13(3):396-401. DOI: 10.3758/bf03193859. View

Badre D, Poldrack R, Pare-Blagoev E, Insler R, Wagner A . Dissociable controlled retrieval and generalized selection mechanisms in ventrolateral prefrontal cortex. Neuron. 2005; 47(6):907-18. DOI: 10.1016/j.neuron.2005.07.023. View

Bloom P, Fischler I . Completion norms for 329 sentence contexts. Mem Cognit. 1980; 8(6):631-42. DOI: 10.3758/bf03213783. View

Tse C, Altarriba J . Testing the associative-link hypothesis in immediate serial recall: Evidence from word frequency and word imageability effects. Memory. 2007; 15(6):675-90. DOI: 10.1080/09658210701467186. View

Barch D, Braver T, Sabb F, Noll D . Anterior cingulate and the monitoriing of response conflict: evidence from an fMRI study of overt verb generation. J Cogn Neurosci. 2000; 12(2):298-309. DOI: 10.1162/089892900562110. View

10.

Wagner A, Clark J, Poldrack R . Recovering meaning: left prefrontal cortex guides controlled semantic retrieval. Neuron. 2001; 31(2):329-38. DOI: 10.1016/s0896-6273(01)00359-2. View

11.

Zbrodoff N . Why is 9 + 7 harder than 2 + 3? Strength and interference as explanations of the problem-size effect. Mem Cognit. 1995; 23(6):689-700. DOI: 10.3758/bf03200922. View

12.

Howard D, Nickels L, Coltheart M, Cole-Virtue J . Cumulative semantic inhibition in picture naming: experimental and computational studies. Cognition. 2006; 100(3):464-82. DOI: 10.1016/j.cognition.2005.02.006. View

13.

DEsposito M, Aguirre G, Farah M . Role of left inferior prefrontal cortex in retrieval of semantic knowledge: a reevaluation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1998; 94(26):14792-7. PMC: 25116. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.94.26.14792. View

14.

Frith C . The role of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex: evidence from the effects of contextual constraint in a sentence completion task. Neuroimage. 2002; 16(4):1094-1102. DOI: 10.1006/nimg.2002.1167. View

15.

Kan I, Thompson-Schill S . Effect of name agreement on prefrontal activity during overt and covert picture naming. Cogn Affect Behav Neurosci. 2004; 4(1):43-57. DOI: 10.3758/cabn.4.1.43. View

16.

Badre D, Wagner A . Left ventrolateral prefrontal cortex and the cognitive control of memory. Neuropsychologia. 2007; 45(13):2883-901. DOI: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2007.06.015. View

17.

Griffiths T, Steyvers M, Tenenbaum J . Topics in semantic representation. Psychol Rev. 2007; 114(2):211-44. DOI: 10.1037/0033-295X.114.2.211. View

18.

Sirotin Y, Kimball D, Kahana M . Going beyond a single list: modeling the effects of prior experience on episodic free recall. Psychon Bull Rev. 2006; 12(5):787-805. DOI: 10.3758/bf03196773. View

19.

Hutchison K . Is semantic priming due to association strength or feature overlap? A microanalytic review. Psychon Bull Rev. 2004; 10(4):785-813. DOI: 10.3758/bf03196544. View

20.

Holroyd C, Coles M . The neural basis of human error processing: reinforcement learning, dopamine, and the error-related negativity. Psychol Rev. 2002; 109(4):679-709. DOI: 10.1037/0033-295X.109.4.679. View