Assessment of Programs for Ligand Binding Affinity Prediction
Overview
Authors
Affiliations
The prediction of the binding free energy between a ligand and a protein is an important component in the virtual screening and lead optimization of ligands for drug discovery. To determine the quality of current binding free energy estimation programs, we examined FlexX, X-Score, AutoDock, and BLEEP for their performance in binding free energy prediction in various situations including cocrystallized complex structures, cross docking of ligands to their non-cocrystallized receptors, docking of thermally unfolded receptor decoys to their ligands, and complex structures with "randomized" ligand decoys. In no case was there a satisfactory correlation between the experimental and estimated binding free energies over all the datasets tested. Meanwhile, a strong correlation between ligand molecular weight-binding affinity correlation and experimental predicted binding affinity correlation was found. Sometimes the programs also correctly ranked ligands' binding affinities even though native interactions between the ligands and their receptors were essentially lost because of receptor deformation or ligand randomization, and the programs could not decisively discriminate randomized ligand decoys from their native ligands; this suggested that the tested programs miss important components for the accurate capture of specific ligand binding interactions.
Saptarini N, Kelutur F, Corpuz M Scientifica (Cairo). 2024; 2024:1558620.
PMID: 38962530 PMC: 11221971. DOI: 10.1155/2024/1558620.
da Silva Arouche T, Lobato J, Dos Santos Borges R, Santana de Oliveira M, de Jesus Chaves Neto A J Mol Model. 2024; 30(7):203.
PMID: 38858279 DOI: 10.1007/s00894-024-05996-z.
Yang C, Zhang Y J Chem Inf Model. 2022; 62(11):2696-2712.
PMID: 35579568 PMC: 9197983. DOI: 10.1021/acs.jcim.2c00485.
Goel H, Hazel A, Ustach V, Jo S, Yu W, MacKerell Jr A Chem Sci. 2021; 12(25):8844-8858.
PMID: 34257885 PMC: 8246086. DOI: 10.1039/d1sc01781k.
Explainable Deep Relational Networks for Predicting Compound-Protein Affinities and Contacts.
Karimi M, Wu D, Wang Z, Shen Y J Chem Inf Model. 2020; 61(1):46-66.
PMID: 33347301 PMC: 7987499. DOI: 10.1021/acs.jcim.0c00866.