Computational and Experimental Studies of the Effect of Substituents on the Singlet-triplet Energy Gap in Phenyl(carbomethoxy)carbene

The effect of aromatic substitution on the singlet-triplet energy gap in substituted phenyl(carbomethoxy)carbene (X-Ph-C-CO(2)CH(3), PCC) has been explored by time-resolved infrared (TRIR) spectroscopy and gas-phase computational methods. The ground state of para-substituted PCC is calculated to change from the triplet state in p-NO(2)-PCC (Delta G(ST) = 6.1 kcal/mol) to the singlet state in p-NH(2)-PCC (Delta G(ST) = -2.8 kcal/mol). The absence of solvent perturbation in the TRIR spectra of p-N(CH(3))(2)-PCC (which should have electronic properties similar to p-NH(2)-PCC) and parent PCC is consistent with their ground states lying > +/-2 kcal/mol from the next available electronic state, in line with the computational results. The observation of solvent perturbation in the TRIR spectra of p-OCH(3)-PCC and p-CH(3)-PCC implies that their ground states lie < +/-1 kcal/mol from their next available electronic state. This is in agreement with our computational results, which predict a gas-phase Delta G(ST) of -0.8 and 1.6 kcal/mol for p-OCH(3)-PCC and p-CH(3)-PCC as compared to Delta G(ST) values of -3.9 and -1.3 kcal/mol from polarizable continuum model (PCM) calculations with acetonitrile as a solvent. Gas-phase computational results for the meta- and ortho-substituted PCC species are also presented, along with selected linear free energy (LFE) relationships for the para and meta species.