Laparoscopic Repair of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease. Toupet Partial Fundoplication Versus Nissen Fundoplication

This report describes our preliminary experience with two surgical laparoscopic fundoplication procedures, the Nissen technique and the Toupet operation, in which the fundal wrap is reduced from 360 degrees to 180-200 degrees. Fourteen patients with symptomatic gastroesophageal reflux disease who were refractory to pharmacologic and medical therapy underwent a laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication; in an additional 14 patients, we performed a laparoscopic Toupet partial fundoplication. Our laparoscopic approach to the two procedures does not differ significantly from the traditional open methods and the effectiveness of the laparoscopic fundoplication procedures appears similar to that of the same conventional techniques. Oral feedings can be resumed on the first postoperative day and patients typically are discharged on the second day after surgery. Operative time for performing the Toupet procedure averaged just approximately 1.6 h and was shorter than that for the Nissen fundoplication, due to the use of a stapler to secure the fundal wrap. Confirming earlier observations, the laparoscopic Toupet 180-200 degrees fundoplication was associated with a lower incidence of postoperative digestive complications, such as dysphagia, than was the laparoscopic Nissen operation. The laparoscopic fundoplication approach offers the advantages of clear visualization, adequate dissection and precise repair, along with the benefits associated with endoscopic surgery: diminished postoperative pain and discomfort, reduced hospitalization, and quicker return to normal activities. Our experience indicates that the Toupet fundoplication may be preferable to the Nissen technique for many patients requiring surgical treatment of their reflux disease.