Mechanistically Different Catalytic Antibodies Obtained from Immunization with a Single Transition-state Analog

The variable-region peptide sequence and steady-state kinetic behavior are compared for a family of catalytic antibodies that arose from the same immune response to a transition-state analog. The crystal structure of the most catalytically active member of the family (17E8) has been solved to 2.5 A resolution and shows that the antibody active site contains a SerH99-HisH35 (H = heavy chain) catalytic dyad analogous to the Ser-His-Asp catalytic triad of serine proteases. The variable-region peptide sequence of the next most active antibody (29G11) differs from that of 17E8 by nine heavy-chain point mutations, and results from computer modeling suggest that the three-dimensional structure of 29G11 is similar to that of 17E8. In addition, 29G11 is an efficient catalytic antibody; it possesses 26% of the hydrolytic activity of 17E8. There is one active-site mutation in 29G11 compared to 17E8; position 99 of the heavy chain of 29G11 contains a glycine residue in place of the nucleophilic serine at this position in 17E8. Consistent with this mutation, results from pH-rate studies and hydroxylamine partitioning experiments indicate that in contrast to the catalytic mechanism of 17E8, the mechanism of 29G11-catalyzed esterolysis does not feature nucleophilic catalysis.