The Efficacy of an Embryonic Stem Cell-based Vaccine for Lung Cancer Prevention Depends on the Undifferentiated State of the Stem Cells

Based on the antigenic similarity between tumor cells and embryonic stem cells (ESCs), several recent studies report the use of intact murine ESCs or exosomes from murine ESCs as cancer vaccines. Since the capacity for self-renewal is one of the most specialized properties shared between ESCs and a subset of tumor cells, cancer stem cells (CSCs), we investigated whether the undifferentiated state of murine ESCs is essential for the prophylactic effectiveness of an ESC-based vaccine. The undifferentiated state of ES-D3, a murine ESC line, was essential for their anchorage-independent growth potential. Importantly, differentiation of ES-D3 cells decreased their efficacy in preventing the outgrowth of implanted lung tumors. Furthermore, the long-term cancer-preventive potential of this vaccine was also inhibited by the differentiation of these cells. To examine the antigenicity of the ESC-derived vaccine, we performed combined affinity chromatography shotgun immunoproteomic experiments to identify antigens specific to the whole-cell ES vaccine as well as to the ESC-derived exosome vaccine. Our data demonstrate that antibodies against several lung cancer-associated keratin members were enriched in the serum of vaccinated mice. In summary, these data suggest that the tumor-preventing efficacy of ESC-based vaccine is reliant on the differentiation properties of these stem cells.