Culture in Cancer Survivorship Interventions for Asian Americans: A Systematic Review and Critical Analyses

Frequently hard to reach and underserved, Asian Americans are the racial group whose chief cause of mortality is cancer. Efficacious survivorship care is important, but little is known about extant intervention efforts for this community and how culture has been integrated into these efforts. This study examined cancer survivorship interventions for Asian Americans and how culture has been addressed, using an integrated framework consisting of goals, theory, methods, and cultural concordance in the persons of the interventions. Mixed methods comprising a systematic review and critical analyses were employed. Results indicate that only 13 interventions have been delivered to this community, with six of them pilot studies, and that they used a narrow range of focus on cancer type, with all interventions focusing on breast cancer survivorship. Applications of theory and methods were incongruent with cultural valuation of emotion expression and help seeking behavior. Cultural concordance was operationalized mostly as the racial ethnic match between interventionists and survivors. Deep culture factors including cultural beliefs and values were rarely specified. Theory and research should move beyond the currently prevalent definition of culture as race, ethnicity, or language, and interventions should consider the role of culture in their goals, theory, methods, and persons. Advances in theory and research are needed, as neither reliance on the Western paradigm nor assumptions about Asian Americans can be appropriate for achieving cultural validity. Future conceptualization and operationalization should consider culture more than race, ethnicity, or language.