The Relative Effects of Collagen Fiber Orientation, Porosity, Density, and Mineralization on Bone Strength

This investigation determined the relative importance of collagen fiber orientation, porosity, density, and mineralization in determining the tensile strength of bovine cortical bone. Thirty-nine specimens were tested for failure stress and the values of eight histologic and compositional parameters: collagen fiber orientation, wet and dry apparent density, percent mineralization of the bone matrix, and several components of porosity (Haversian canals, Volkmann's canals, and plexiform vascular spaces). Linear regression analysis showed that collagen fiber orientation was consistently the single best predictor of strength. Mineralization of the bone matrix was generally a poor predictor of strength. Density and porosity ranked between these variables in importance. Multiple regression equations containing all significantly correlated variables achieved correlation coefficients of 0.607 for plexiform bone and 0.881 for osteonal bone. Also, separate analysis of plexiform and osteonal specimens showed that the latter group was weaker even though it was less porous, apparently because it had collagen fibers which were less longitudinally oriented. This study suggests it is feasible to develop better empirical formulae for the prediction of cortical bone strength than are currently available if a variety of variables is introduced. Additional data are needed to confirm these results.