Influence of Abasic and Anucleosidic Sites on the Stability, Conformation, and Melting Behavior of a DNA Duplex: Correlations of Thermodynamic and Structural Data

We report a complete thermodynamic characterization of the impact of abasic and anucleosidic lesions on the stability, conformation, and melting behavior of a DNA duplex. The requisite thermodynamic data were obtained by using a combination of spectroscopic and calorimetric techniques to investigate helix-to-coil transitions in a family of DNA duplexes of the form d(CGCATGAGTACGC).d(GCGTACXCATGCG), where X corresponds to a thymidine residue in the parent Watson-Crick duplex and to an abasic or anucleosidic site in the modified duplexes. The data derived from these studies reveal that incorporation of an abasic site into a DNA duplex dramatically reduces the duplex stability, transition enthalpy, and transition entropy. The magnitudes of these lesion-induced effects are greater than one would expect based on simple nearest-neighbor considerations. Nearly identical thermodynamic data are obtained when the modified duplex contains an anucleosidic site rather than an abasic site. This observation suggests that the thermodynamic impact of these lesions primarily results from removal of the base rather than the sugar ring. Significantly, the melting cooperativities of the abasic and anucleosidic derivatives are identical with each other and with the corresponding unmodified Watson-Crick parent duplex. This result suggests that the phosphodiester backbone, rather than the base-sugar network, serves as the primary propagation path for the communication of cooperative melting effects. We propose molecular interpretations for the thermodynamic data based on the structural picture that has emerged from the NMR studies of Patel and coworkers on the same family of modified and unmodified DNA duplexes [Kalnik, M.W., Chang, C.-N., Grollman, A.P. & Patel, D.J. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 924-931].