Bowel Obstruction Rates in Antecolic/antegastric Versus Retrocolic/retrogastric Roux Limb Gastric Bypass: a Meta-analysis

Background: Previous literature is varied with regard to rates of bowel obstruction after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (LRYGB). Internal herniation through mesenteric defects is a common cause of bowel obstructions. There are advantages and disadvantages to routing the Roux limb via a retrocolic/retrogastric (RC/RG) versus an antecolic/antegastric (AC/AG) position.

Objective: To review the literature comparing obstruction rates in RYGB using the antecolic versus retrocolic approach.

Setting: Community-based integrated multispecialty health system with a teaching hospital serving 19 counties over a 3-state region.

Methods: A literature search for articles published from 1994-2013 was completed. Articles were included if they reported an n>25, Roux limb route, obstruction rate by route, and follow-up duration. Statistical analysis included χ(2) test by patient number.

Results: The initial search identified 241 articles; 8 met inclusion criteria. There were 4805 patients in the AC/AG group, and 2238 in the RC/RG group. Follow-up ranged from 0 to 68 months. A linear stapled technique was reported in 4231 (88%) patients in the AC/AG group and 1541 (69%) of RC/RG group. Handsewn closure of mesenteric defects was reported in 2152 (45%) patients in the AC/AG group and 1012 (45%) patients in the RC/RG group. Bowel obstructions occurred in 68 (1.4%) patients in the AC/AG group and 117 (5.2%) patients in the RC/RG group (P<.001). Internal hernias were reported in 65 (1.3%) patients in the AC/AG group and 52 (2.3%) patients in the RC/RG group (P<.001). Two mortalities were reported in the AC/AG group.

Conclusions: Increased rates of bowel obstruction and internal hernia were observed in the RC/RG group compared with the AC/AG group. A prospective, randomized trial would be necessary to definitively determine the impact of Roux limb position and routine closure of mesenteric defects on bowel obstruction rates after gastric bypass.