The In-vitro Spheroid Culture Induces a More Highly Differentiated but Tumorigenic Population from Melanoma Cell Lines

Cancer stem cells (CSCs) have been identified in various malignancies, and different properties have been examined to characterize CSCs: tumorigenicity in immunocompromised mice, stem cell surface markers, label-retaining properties, and proliferation as nonadherent spheres. This study explored the consistency and efficiency among these methods. Among the melanoma cell lines examined (A375, A875, MUM-2b, and MUM-2c), only A375 and MUM-2c grew as nonadherent spheres and continuously propagated in a defined serum-free medium in vitro. Flow cytometry and immunofluorescence analysis indicated that sphere-derived cells contained a smaller proportion of cells expressing the candidate surface markers of melanoma stem cells such as ABCB5, CD133, CD20 and CD271, and a larger proportion of cells expressing melanocytic differentiation markers such as HMB45 and S100 protein, compared with adherent cells. Surprisingly, the more highly differentiated sphere-derived melanoma cells exhibited increased tumorigenic potential in vivo, as indicated by shorter tumor incubation (A375) and smaller number of cells required to initiate tumor formation (A375 and MUM-2c) compared with those of parental cells. Despite the similarity in histopathological characteristics, the expression profile indicated that xenografts derived from sphere-derived melanoma cells exhibited a more tumorigenic phenotype with respect to the stem or the differentiation markers detected by immunohistochemical analysis. Therefore, sphere formation in nonadherent cultures may not be a preferred surrogate in-vitro method for enriching melanoma stem cells according to candidate markers but may be a favorable condition for activating potential CSCs.