Stem Cell Clonality and Genotoxicity in Hematopoietic Cells: Gene Activation Side Effects Should Be Avoidable

Two serious adverse events involving activation of the LMO2 oncogene through retrovirus vector insertion in the otherwise extremely successful first gene therapy trial for X-linked severe combined immunodeficieny type 1 (SCID-X1) had initially caused widespread concern in the patient and research communities. Careful consideration 1 year after diagnosis of the second case still finds 12 of the treated patients clearly benefiting from gene therapy (freedom from treatment failure, 80%; survival 100%), a situation that should not portend the end of gene therapy for this disease, and is, in fact encouraging. While current approaches are justified to treat patients with otherwise life-threatening disorders, a broad consensus has developed that systematic basic research is required to further understand the pathophysiology of these serious adverse events and to provide new insights, enabling safer and more effective gene therapy strategies. With the continued success of SCID-X1 gene therapy in the majority of patients treated, it is of even greater importance to understand exactly which vector element or combination of elements predispose to toxicity. An in-depth study of the mechanisms behind the activation of the LMO2 and gammac genes will be highly instructive for the development of safer procedures and vectors. We summarize the central observations, ongoing experimental approaches, new concepts, and developments relevant to understanding, interpreting, and eventually overcoming the real and perceived obstacles posed by insertional mutagenesis due to gene transfer vectors.