Interleukin 1 and Receptor Antagonist Levels in Gingival Crevicular Fluid in Heavy Smokers Versus Non-smokers

Background/aims: This study aimed to investigate the concentration of the cytokine interleukin (IL)-1beta and its receptor antagonist IL-1ra in gingival crevicular fluid (GCF) in patients with adult periodontitis who were heavy smokers compared with non-smokers.

Method: GCF samples were collected from two groups of subjects: smokers and non-smokers. Thirty-nine GCF samples were harvested from 13 subjects with moderate to severe adult periodontitis who were heavy smokers. A further 30 GCF samples were harvested from 10 subjects with moderate to severe adult periodontitis who were non-smokers. Subjects were selected from both genders and none had any relevant systemic illness, were pregnant, had recent medication or had received any periodontal therapy in the preceding 3 months. One deep bleeding site, one deep non-bleeding site and one healthy site were investigated in each subject. Clinical measurements were recorded for each site, after obtaining a GCF sample using a Periopaper strip. IL-1beta and IL-1ra were quantified using new commercially available ELISA kits (Quantikine), and could be detected in all samples.

Results: For smokers, the mean concentrations for IL-1beta were 2714.5 (SD 4416.2) pg/ micro L for healthy sites, 37.0 (SD 57.2) pg/ micro L for non-bleeding periodontitis sites and 24.5 (SD 29.2) pg/ micro L for bleeding periodontitis sites. The concentrations of IL-1beta for non-smokers for the same category of sites were 393.8 (SD 867.1), 74.2 (SD 107.0) and 73.1 (SD 61.0) pg/ micro L, respectively. The mean concentrations of IL-1ra for smokers were 5.8 x 10(5) (SD 9.7) pg/ micro L for healthy sites, 2.2 x 10(5) (SD 0.15) pg/ micro L for deep non-bleeding sites and 0.19 x 10(5) (SD 0.07) pg/ micro L for deep bleeding sites. The concentrations for non-smokers were: 4.1 x 10(10) (SD 3.8), 18.1 x 10(5) (SD 20.4) and 3.2 x 10(5) (SD 2.3) pg/ micro L, respectively. Significance levels of P < 0.05 were found for comparisons of healthy vs. deep bleeding and deep non-bleeding sites for IL-1beta and IL-1ra in smokers, before adjustments for multiple testing. However, none of these comparisons reached statistical significance following adjustments for multiple testing. P < 0.05 for the correlation between IL-1beta and IL-1ra at healthy sites in smokers only. Differences in GCF concentrations for IL-1beta in smokers vs. non-smokers were significant for deep bleeding sites only (P < 0.05), the mean concentration of IL-1beta being lower in GCF from smokers vs. non-smokers. All differences in GCF concentrations of IL-1ra reached statistical significance for smokers vs. non-smokers. The mean concentrations of IL-1ra in GCF were lower in smokers compared with non-smokers for all categories of sites.

Conclusions: A decreased concentration of IL-1beta and also IL-1ra was found in GCF from periodontitis sites compared to healthy sites in smokers and in non-smokers, although this did not reach statistical significance following adjustments for multiple testing. For comparisons between heavy smokers and non-smokers, statistically significant differences were found in the GCF concentrations of IL-1beta from deep bleeding sites only. Statistically significant differences were found in the IL-1ra concentrations for smokers vs. non-smokers for all categories of sites.