Reproducibility of Sequential Head-up Tilt Testing in Patients with Recent Syncope, Normal ECG and No Structural Heart Disease

Aims: To assess the reproducibility of the response to sequential head-up tilt tests.

Methods And Results: A head-up tilt test was performed early after syncope in 127 patients with a normal ECG and no structural heart disease. Patients with a positive response (82 patients) were randomized to two (1 week and 2 weeks later) or one (2 weeks later) additional head-up tilt tests, and patients with a negative response (45 patients) were randomized to a second head-up tilt test 1 or 2 weeks after the first. The reproducibility of a positive response in the second head-up tilt test was 80% after 1 week and 53% after 2 weeks (P<0.01). Only 53% of the patients with a positive response to a first and second head-up tilt test had a positive response to a third (P=0.01). Intra-individual variation in the time to a positive response was wide. The reproducibility of the cardioinhibitory responses was very poor. Reproducibility of a negative response was 80%.

Conclusions: In patients with recent syncope, the rate of positive responses decreases with sequential head-up tilt tests. Furthermore, the time to a positive response in different head-up tilt tests shows important intra-individual variations, and the reproducibility of the cardioinhibitory responses is very poor. In contrast, the reproducibility of the negative responses is high.