Viewpoint: Are Studies in Genetically Altered Mice out of Control?

Because the use of transgenic and gene-targeted models has increased in popularity, the number of reports describing unpredictable phenotypic effects caused by variation in the genetic background used to generate or propagate these models has steadily increased. There are now many examples in which animals containing the same exact genetic manipulation exhibit profoundly different phenotypes when present on diverse genetic backgrounds, demonstrating that genes unrelated, per se, to the ones being targeted can play a significant role in the observed phenotype. Herein, I will discuss (1) the source of genetic variability in mutant mouse models, (2) the appropriateness of using inbred mice as controls, and (3) strategies to help minimize genetic variation between experimental and control mice.